This paper presents the solutions of Selective Harmonic Elimination problem based on an imperialist competitive algorithm. This method for eliminating harmonics particularly predetermined harmonics of the 9-level inverter. Minimize the harmonic is the difficult problems because of the nonlinear transcendental equations is ordered to find out the switching angles, controlling inverter output voltage and also minimized Total Harmonic Distortion of output voltage.. The proposed method is able to eliminate the high number of predetermine harmonics. Simulation work is achieved by using the MATLAB software which verifies the proposed method and finally Total Harmonic Distortion comparison is presented for analysis.
Keywords |
SHE-PWM, Imperialist Competitive Algorithm, THD |
INTRODUCTION |
In modern years, there is a developing demand for conversion systems,intelligent of furnishing high output voltage
and carrying good spectral analysis easy control. The evaluations of FACTS devices, medium voltage drives, and
different types of renewable energy resources have given strong freedom for the Voltage control techniques are derived
whereby harmonic elimination is possible in variable-frequency variable-voltage three-phase inverter circuits[1-3]. The
fundamental issue with these applications is the frequency restraint of the pulse width modulation which is restricted by
electromagnetic interferences and switching losses which is the conclusion of high dV/dt. Thus, to overcome this
specified problem, SHE based optimal pulse width modulation are proposed which are adept to reduce the harmonics
and the THD of output voltage [6-7]. An ordinary multilevel inverter applies several DC voltage sources to appoint a
step by step waveform in output voltage which makes a huge growth on output voltage THD at the same time output
waveform way nearly sinusoidal waveform [8]. Alike to the inverter circuit model the DC sources can be
corresponding [7]. |
As a result of the complexity of SHE problem, in utmost studies on the SHE methods for Multi Level Inverters, it is
pretended that only one switching angle per every voltage level is defined and the DC sources are balanced. But in
empirical applications, contingent on the output waveform and operating system of the inverter, the DC sources may be
unbalanced or several switching’s per each level are involved [9–13]. SHE method is a modulation strategy whose
objective is to complete the suitable switching angles to eliminate the number of lower-order harmonics which agent to
reduce the output waveform Total Harmonic Distortion [14]. The SHE method essential low switching frequency and
step by step output voltage waveform to be applied [15]. The basic target in SHE method is to find out the switching
angles in which with the achieve switching angles the fundamental component's ability to the want value and the
unwanted harmonics; fundamentally lower-order harmonics are eliminated [16]. |
The assign objective function for SHE problem contains a set of nonlinear equations which may include various local
optima. Determine the SHE problem is accessible with the help of various processes. Resultant theory is an original
which is standing on analytical calculations [17]. In resultant algorithm method the support equations which are details
for SHE are modified into an equivalent set of polynomial, and next resultant theory is proven to the get equivalent
equations which are generally high order polynomials. The basic problem with this method is the intricacy of
calculation. The intricacy boost when the number of switching angles is raised and so makes the equivalent equation,
solid to be resolved or even not to be solved. Addition method for solving is the NR method, and it is a Numeric
iterative technique [18]. However, the huge difficulty of these techniques is the fitting initial guess necessity that should be near to the correct solution. It is clear that giving a proper guess is very challenging in most cases, but if a
suitable initial guess is available, the Newton - Raphson method works perfectly. This trouble is the result of the SHE
problem search space which is foreign for anybody, and no one notice whether a solution happen or not, and if survive,
what is the suitable initial guess. |
|
A newly growth, innovative method to accord with the SHE problem is based on developmental algorithms such as
Honey Bee algorithm [19]. However the search space complexity would increase Cleary if the number of switching
angle increases and both methods fall into the ambush of local optimum points of search space. Absolutely, the exact
restraint for the number of switching angles can't be finding out in evolutionary algorithms [20]. So, raising the
number of switching angles reduces the possibility of concluding the best switching angles, unfortunately [21-22].
The SHE-PWM is innovative methods that bring more number of the degrees of accuracy and makes ready to use
eliminate many harmonic elements with no need to change the observable model of the inverter [23-24]. |
In SHE-PWM, each device can be switched at minimum double per cycle, and number of harmonic elements than in
the case of intrinsic frequency switching strategy can be eliminated. The major issue affiliated to the Selective
Harmonic Elimination –Pulse Width Modulation technique is that as the number of switching pulse values is
increased; none of prior methods can be used to find out the switching angles. In this paper, a growth method based
on Imperialist Competitive Algorithm is developed to bargain with the SHE-PWM problem. Simulation results are
achieved for a 9-level cascaded multilevel inverter to certify the efficiency of the advanced method and accuracy. The
vacation of this paper is formed as follows. Section 2 characterizes the multilevel inverter output and its harmonic
spectrum. Section 3 defines the Selective Harmonic Elimination approach objective. In Section 4, the achieved
simulation results are presented. Also to reform the efficacy of the SHE, a valuable solution is presented. Section 6 is
detailed for the conclusion. |
OUTPUT VOLTAGE OF MULTILEVEL INVERTER |
A classic waveform of the mention phase voltage of a 9-level inverter integrates several DC sources using Selective
Harmonic Elimination-Pulse Width Modulation method is illustrated in Figure:1. The α1− 5 are the necessary
switching angles to indicate the complete cycle of the display waveform. Concerning Figure 1 the reference voltage,
vref, can be displayed in condition of step function (ωt). For positive half cycle of the waveform: |
|
Va = Vap + Van (3) |
To identify the immediate value of reference voltage the Fourier analysis is tested a and the following expression is
achieved. If the given waveform in figure 1 was treated for one cycle, it can be noticed that it's an odd function and so
it will consist of only odd-order harmonic:To identify the immediate value of reference voltage the Fourier analysis is
tested a and the following expression is achieved. If the given waveform in figure:2 was treated for one cycle, it can be
noticed that it's an odd function and so it will consist of only odd-order harmonic: |
|
Staircase voltage waveform and again. The objective of SHE-PWM method is calculated to selected the set of
switching angle value α1−α 5 such that the identified predetermined harmonics are put down, and, at the same instant
,he amplitude of fundamental component comes equal to the needed value. |
SELECTIVE HARMONIC ELIMINATION-ICA |
In utmost papers, the output voltage waveform is studied in SHE method in MLIs [23, 3]. In this subject, for a 2 s + 1
level inverter, S denotes number of levels. The number of switching in a one fourth of a cycle is restricted to s, where
s is the number of sources. So the number of selective harmonics which can be eliminated from the voltage is s − 1. In
order to increase the degree of freedoms and eliminating many harmonics than the case of fundamental switching
scheme without any control of inverters hardware, the SHE-PWM technique is planned in [12], which is also
denominated basic stage PWM. This method is one of the powerful belief that employee to MLIs in order to generate
high-quality output voltage waveform to a less power switching frequency in comparison with other methods. The
general formula to eliminate predetermine harmonics in multilevel inverter with no equal DC sources is also submitted
in [21]. |
Commonly, the number of switching angles can vary in different levels. However, for Cleary, the number of switching
is calculated to be equivalent in this paper for different voltage levels. Figure 1 are presents the output voltage of Ninelevel
inverter for three times of switching angle at each level. If k denotes the number of switching at every level,
switching frequency of the SHE-PWM system will be k times the fundamental frequency. Then, the number of
harmonics possible to eliminate from the output voltage is appraised by k × s − 1 for the Nine level. For k = 3, The
Selective Harmonic Elimination Pulse Width Modulation method is able to eliminate the no triple low-order harmonics
up to 3ks−2. So KS is odd, up to 3ks−1, being while ks is even. |
|
Its observable that eliminating the triple harmonics is not essential for three-phase applications because these
harmonics should underbelly be removed from the line voltage. A 9-level inverter is denoted as a case study to
calculate the impact of Selective Harmonic Elimination-Pulse Width Modulation on its harmonic spectrum analysis.
The basic objective function for a Nine-level inverter is the issue of a consolidation of 5 non-linear equations that one
equation is for the fundamental harmonic component and the other equations are similar to the unwanted harmonics. |
|
|
In this paper ICA is used to answer the defined problem. An imperialist competitive algorithm is a recently developed
optimization method which is implemented by imperialist competition. Like the other new evolutionary algorithm, to
solve a problem, it needed an initial. A population in which absolutely one of them will be the fitting solution of the
preceding problem. Initial population is the sum of the countries which is branching into colonies and imperialists
which together form empires. One imperialist with suitable colonies creates an empire. |
Based on absorption policy, the colonies start groping toward their applicable imperialist state as long as developing
their economy, culture, political, and social position. The total power of a control is the worth of imperialist power and
the percentage of suitable colony's power. During the specified competition, all empires try to take control of colonies
of other empires just before the weak control collapse and just one most robust control exists which the Imperialist and
the suitable colonies get the same value of the cost function. So, in this case with most robust rule is the convergence
point of ICA. Figure 3 illustrates the flow chart of ICA. With regard to the approach of SHE, variables are the
switching pulses of the 9-level inverter. |
SIMULATION RESULTS |
The SHE method applies to the 9-level inverter and the simulation results are obtained. The equivalent optimum
switching angles Vs the modulation index is denoted in Figure 5 displays the amplitude of the fundamental component
Vs modulation index. It can be noticed from this diagram that the amplitude of unwanted harmonics has very low
values and extremely the presented method can absolutely eliminate the harmonic components in figure :4 |
|
|
|
|
The attain solutions for the switching pulse and the comparable cost values are represented in table 1, appropriately. |
|
Finally the THD values display in Figure 6, it is probable that the Imperialist Competitive Algorithm is efficiency
able to find out the best switching angles to fitting the objective function which aims to reach the fundamental
component and put down the unwanted harmonics and THD. As decorated before, there is no hope of fitting the
objective function all value where SHE is applied. As displayed in Figure 7 it is objective that for any ranges of
modulation index the value of the cost function is very low THD and it means that all unwanted harmonics get nearly
to zero. |
|
The values of modulation index with higher ranges of cost function mean that the ranges of h the harmonic spectrum
component are nonzero, and so the equations can’t be determined and there is no solution. |
|
Generally in the perfect ranges of modulation index, displayed in Figure7, the important component is kept close to the
wanted value. Establish to display simulation results it can be view that there are some domain of modulation index in
which the best value of switching angles do not exist. |
|
CONCLUSION |
An ICA has been proposed to complete the optimum switching angle value of a 9-level inverter. This method gives the
lower percentage Total Harmonic Distortion compared to the other Iterative methods. In recent years the design for
elimination of harmonics in MLI by using the Imperialist Competitive Algorithm method has been completed by taking
excellent switching angle values as the objective function. In this task low order harmonics have been completely
eliminated by using the equation for Total Harmonic Distortion as the objective function and have given excellent
results in minimization of Total Harmonic Distortion. |
References |
- Power Electronics: Converters, Applications, and Design by N. Mohan,W. P. Robbins.
- Patel and Hoft,"Generalized Harmonic Elimination in Thyristor Inverters Application", IEEE Transaction India, volume 10,issue 4,page 666– 673,September 1974.
- Jason R. Wells,"SHE Control: A General Problem Formulation", IEEE Transaction, volume 20,issue 6,page1337–1345 November 2005.
- F. G. Turnbull,"Selected Harmonic Reduction in Static Inverters/Converter,"IEEETransaction,Volume 83,issue 73,page 374–378May 1964.
- Ozpineci, Chiasson,"Harmonic Optimization of MLI using GA",IEEE Transcation,Volume 5,issue 3911–3916,September 2005.
- Farokhnia, N Tehran,Fathi,"Direct Nonlinear Control for Individual DC Voltage Balancing in Cascaded Multilevel DSTATCOM", EPESC 09, Page 1–7,November 2009.
- Fu–San Shyu,Nat,Yen–Shin Lai,"Virtual Stage Pulse–Width Modulation Technique for Multilevel Inverter/Converter," IEEE Transaction on Power electronics,Volume 17,issue 3 may 2002.
- L. Li D. Czarkowski,"MLI SHE– PWM Technique", IEEE Transactions,volume 36,issue 23, May 2000
- Diong, K. Corzine, "Multilevel Inverter Based Dual Frequency",IEEE Transaction, Volume 1, issue 4,page 115–119,December 2003.
- P. M. Bhagwat "Generalized Structure of A Multilevel Pulse Width Mouldation Inverter", IEEE Transaction India, volume 19,issue 6,page 1057–1069,Nov/Dec. 1983.
- Mosa,Abu–Rub,Kouzou,"Control of Single Phase Gird Connected Multilevel Inverter Using Model Predictive Control method", PEEED,page 624–628,May 2013.
- Marzoughi A, ImaneiniH,"An Optimal Selective Harmonic Mitigation for Cascaded H–Bridge Converters",EEEIC,International Conference, Volume 11, page 752–757,May 2012.
- Zhong du, Leon M Tolbert, "Reduced Switching–Frequency AHE for MLI", IEEE Transaction volume 55, April 2008.
- Banaei M.R, Salary E, " New MLI with Reduction of Switches And Gate Driver", Iranian Conference, Electrical Engineering ,May 2010.
- AdelehShahipour, BehroozVahild, " THD Minimization Applied Directly on The Phase Voltage Of Multilevel Inverters by using Imperialist Competitive",international journal of science, page 57–63Janurary 2014.
- Dahidah, Mohamed, Semenyih, "Non Symmetrical SHE–PWM technique for Five Level Cascaded Converter with Non Equal Dc Sources, Power and Energy Conference, 2nd international conference, page 775–780Decemember 2008.
- Kouzou. A, Mahmoudi.M.O,"Application of SHE–PWM for Seven âÃâ¬Ãâ Level Inverter Output Voltage Enhancement Based on Particle Swarm Optimization", multi–international conference, page 1–6,June 2010.
- Chiasson, Tolbert, "A Unified Approach to Solving The Harmonic Elimination Equations in MLI", IEEE transaction,volume 19, issue 2,page 478–490,March 2004.
- Al–Othman, Abdelhamid, "Elimination of Harmonic in Multilevel inverters with Non Equal DC Sources Using Particle Swarm Optimization",PEMCCC,page 606–613,Septemeber 2008.
- Naderi.Y, Hosseini.S.H," A New Control Strategy for Harmonic Minimization based on triple switching of MLI",21st Iranian Conference,page 1–6,May 2013.
- Etesami.M.H, Farokhnia, "A method based on an Imperialist Competitive algorithm, aiming to mitigate harmonic in multilevel inverters", PEDSC, page 1–6,Feburary 2011.
- Kavousi.A,Tehran, " Application of the Honey bee algorithm for SHE strategy in MLIS", IEEE Transactions Power Electronics, volume 27, April 2012.
- Ahmadi.D,KeZou,Cong Li " A Universal SHE Method for High power Applications",IEEE Transaction, Volume 26, issue 10,page 2743– 2752,October 2011.
- Van–Tung,Hong–Hee, " Control Strategy for Harmonic in Stand Alone DFIG Applications with Nonlinear Loads ", IEEE Transaction, Power Electronics, Volume 26, September 2011.
|