International Journal of Innovative Research in Science, Engineering and Technology

International Journal of Innovative Research in Science, Engineering and Technology

Menu

ISSN ONLINE(2319-8753)PRINT(2347-6710)

All submissions of the EM system will be redirected to Online Manuscript Submission System. Authors are requested to submit articles directly to Online Manuscript Submission System of respective journal.

Impact of Quality Dimensions of Banking Services onthe Banks Financial Resources Mobilization Based on SERVQUAL Model (Case Study Bank Melli Branches in Gilan)

Dr. M. H. Gholizadeh1.Dr. M. Taleghani2.J.Pirdehghan3
  1. Department of Business Management, Guilan University, Guilan, Iran
  2. Departmentof Industrial Management, Islamic Azad University, Rasht Branch, Rasht, Iran
  3. M.A. of Business Management, Islamic Azad University, Rasht Branch, Rasht, Iran (Corresponding Author)
Related article at Pubmed, Scholar Google

Visit for more related articles at International Journal of Innovative Research in Science, Engineering and Technology

International Journal of Innovative Research in Science, Engineering and Technology

Abstract

In today's competitive world competition increased intensity in all economic, industrial, and business activities including banking industry. Nowadays quality is not only as a competitive factor, rather it plays a role as survival factor in competitive market. Banking system in the economy has heavy responsibility and it is considered one of the most important pillars of the economy. Each monetary economy has financial system and banks are basic element of this system and also survival continuity of banks is depending on deposits (Mobilization Sources). Usually in bank activities attract funds has great importance, because success in this field can be success factor in other fields. In fact, deposits constitute axis and column banking operations and doing other tasks and banking operations is depending on deposits. In other words, this basic task is precedence over the other banking tasks. Quality measurement in the banks is very important due to apparent relationship with costs, profitability, customer satisfaction. Therefore for lower costs is Basic and main key factors such as profitability and customer satisfaction, quality of banking services, and its increasing. The main objective of this research was impact of quality dimensions of banking services on the banks financial resources Mobilization based on SERVQUAL model

Keywords
Quality, Banking Services, SERVQUAL Model, Mobilization of Resources, Melli Bank

INTRODUCTION
CHANGE SPEED INTENSITY AND EXISTENCE DIFFICULT COMPETITIONS IN VARIOUS AREAS OF DEVELOPMENTS IN TECHNOLOGY, COMPETITION SPREAD, AND GLOBALIZATION HAS FACED COMPLEX AND DYNAMIC ENVIRONMENTS OF ORGANIZATIONS WITH MANY CHALLENGES FOR CONTINUED SURVIVAL [19]IN TODAY'S COMPETITIVE AND TURBULENT ENVIRONMENT ORGANIZATIONS ARE MORE SUCCESSFUL IN THE FIELD OF COMPETITION FOR MEETING THE NEEDS AND CUSTOMER DEMANDS TAKE OVERTAKING FROM OTHER COMPETITORS. IN OTHER WORDS, ORGANIZATIONS PLACED CONSUMER IN CENTER OF ATTENTION AND DO LOOK TO ISSUES FROM CUSTOMER'S PERSPECTIVE (1). ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT INSTITUTIONS IN TODAY SOCIETY IS BANK. NOWADAYS BANKS HAVE BEEN IN DAILY LIVES OF PEOPLE AS IT SEEMS IMPOSSIBLE IMAGINE LIFE WITHOUT A BANK. BANK STRONG TIED WITH CONCEPT OF MONEY THAT FLOWING MONEY IN SOCIETY VESSELS. USUALLY IN BANK ACTIVITIES OF ATTRACT FUNDS IS VERY IMPORTANT. BECAUSE SUCCESS IN THIS FIELD CAN BE SUCCESS FACTOR IN OTHER FIELDS. IN FACT, DEPOSITS CONSTITUTE AXIS AND COLUMN BANKING OPERATIONS AND DOING OTHER TASKS AND BANKING OPERATIONS IS DEPENDING ON DEPOSITS. IN OTHER WORDS, THIS BASIC TASK IS PRECEDENCE OVER THE OTHER BANKING TASKS. ATTRACT FUNDS FOR EACH BANK AND BANKING SYSTEM DEPENDS TO WITHIN ORGANIZATIONAL AND OUTSIDE ORGANIZATIONAL FACTORS. (5)
MOBILIZATION MONEY RESOURCES BEGAN OUTSET HUMAN SOCIAL LIFE AND THEY DEAL TO GOODS TRADE AND EXCHANGE AND ALWAYS BEEN THE MAIN TASK OF THE BANKING SYSTEM. (8)

PROBLEM STATEMENT
BANKING SYSTEM IN THE ECONOMY HAS HEAVY RESPONSIBILITY AND IT IS CONSIDERED MOST IMPORTANT PILLARS OF THE ECONOMY. EACH MONETARY ECONOMY HAS FINANCIAL SYSTEM AND BANKS ARE BASIC ELEMENT OF THIS SYSTEM AND CONTINUITY OF BANKS SURVIVAL IS DEPENDING ON DEPOSITS. KEY TO SUCCESS SERVICE PROVIDER TOP ORGANIZATIONS CAN BE SEARCHED IN CUSTOMER ORIENTATION AND ATTENTION TO QUALITY OF ITS SERVICES. CUSTOMER SATISFACTION WILL HAVE LARGE INFLUENCE ON ORGANIZATIONS PRESENT AND FUTURE LIFE (10). IN TODAY'S COMPETITIVE WORLD HAS ENDED ARENA OF DOMINATION ON CUSTOMERS AND SUCCESS OF ORGANIZATIONS IS DEPENDS ON THE SATISFACTION OF CUSTOMERS AND APPLYING PRINCIPLES OF CUSTOMER ORIENTATION. ATTENTION TO SERVICE QUALITY OF PROVIDED TO CUSTOMERS IN BANKS IS IMPORTANT FACTOR IN ACQUIRING CUSTOMER SATISFACTION AND THEIR ATTRACTING FINANCIAL SOURCES. ON THE OTHER, WITH RISE PUBLIC WELFARE LEVEL AND INCREASE THE PEOPLE EXPECTATIONS LEVEL, SERVICE QUALITY IN BANKS SHOULD BE CONSIDERED AS A SURVIVAL FACTOR AND NOT AS A DIFFERENTIATING COMPETITIVE FACTOR. (13)

PREVIOUS RESEARCH
1. EVALUATION AND ASSESSMENT OF SERVICE QUALITY IN PARSIAN BANK AND ITS RELATIONSHIP WITH CUSTOMER SATISFACTION
ALI MAHDILOOTAZEHKANDI
THE RESULTS SHOW THAT THERE IS A POSITIVE AND SIGNIFICANT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CUSTOMER SATISFACTION AND SERVICE QUALITY. ALSO THERE IS SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCES AMONG PRIORITY FORMATIVE FACTORS OF SERVICE QUALITY. (12)
2. STUDY OF SUCCESS KEY FACTORS OF BANKS IN ATTRACT RESOURCES NON-ACCRUAL (SAVINGS AND CURRENT LOAN) IN MASKAN BANK
DARABASADI
THE RESULTS SHOW THAT AMOUNT OF USE COMPUTER TECHNOLOGY, EMPLOYEE SKILLS, VARIETY OF SERVICES, SERVICE QUALITY, CUSTOMER SATISFACTION FROM ORGANIZATION EMPLOYEE, BRANCHES INTERNAL ENVIRONMENT UTILITY, BRANCHES LOCATION UTILITY, AND ADVERTISING IS EFFECTIVE ON THE ATTRACT NONACCRUAL RESOURCES. (2)
3. MEASURING THE QUALITY OF MASKAN BANK BASED ON THE SERVQUAL MODEL (MASKAN BANK, SUPERVISION UNIT GUILAN)
HASANFAGHIHAKHLAGHI
THE FINDINGS SUGGEST THAT IN %95 CONFIDENCE LEVEL IN ALL FIVE DIMENSIONS OF SERVICE QUALITY CUSTOMER EXPECTATIONS IS BEYOND BANK PERFORMANCE IN PROVIDING SERVICES (CUSTOMER PERCEPTION) AND ALSO THERE ARE GAPS IN ALL DIMENSIONS OF SERVICE QUALITY AND INTANGIBLE FACTORS IS MOST IMPORTANT AND GUARANTEE FACTOR IS LEAST IMPORTANT, FROM RESPONDENTS' VIEW. (3)
4. REVIEW AND MEASURING OF SERVICES QUALITY AND ITS RELATIONSHIP WITH CUSTOMER SATISFACTION : CASE STUDY TEJARAT BANK
SOMAYEHGHADERI ET AL.
THE FINDINGS INDICATE THAT ALL HYPOTHESES WERE CONFIRMED. ALSO THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DIMENSIONS OF SERVICES QUALITY AND CUSTOMER SATISFACTION. THE EMPATHY DIMENSION HAS HIGHEST CORRELATION WITH CUSTOMER SATISFACTION. (6)

Models of Research
image

The Research Hypotheses
THE MAIN HYPOTHESIS : THERE ARE SIGNIFICANT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DIMENSIONS OF BANKING SERVICES QUALITY AND BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization.
THE FIRST SUB-HYPOTHESIS : THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DIMENSION OF TANGIBLE FACTORS AND BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization.
THE SECOND SUB-HYPOTHESIS : THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DIMENSION OF DEPENDABILITY AND BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization.
THE THIRD SUB-HYPOTHESIS : THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DIMENSION OF ACCOUNTABILITY AND BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization.
THE FOURTH SUB-HYPOTHESIS : THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DIMENSION OF RELIABILITY AND BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization.
THE FIFTH SUB-HYPOTHESIS : THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DIMENSION OF EMPATHY AND BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization.

THEORETICAL RESEARCH
SERVICE QUALITY : QUALITY IS CUSTOMER'S JUDGMENTAL (ATTITUDE) AND ALSO DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CUSTOMER EXPECTATIONS FROM WHAT THE ORGANIZATION SHOULD PROVIDE AND RECEIVED SERVICES PERFORMANCE. (9)
TANGIBLE FACTORS : IT IS APPEARANCE OF PHYSICAL FACILITIES AND Mobilization, EMPLOYEES, AVAILABLE COMMUNICATION TOOLS IN PLACE OF SERVICES SUPPLY. (14)
DEPENDABILITY : IT IS ABILITY TO PROMISED SERVICE EXECUTE AND PROVIDE SOMEHOW APPROPRIATE, ACCURATE AND DEPENDABLE. (7)
ACCOUNTABILITY : IT IS WILLINGNESS TO HELP CUSTOMERS AND DELIVER THE IMMEDIATE SERVICES TO THEM. (15)
RELIABILITY : COORDINATION OF PERSONNEL IN PROVIDE EXPECTED SERVICE LEVELS SOMEHOW RELIABLY AND ACCURATELY AND ALSO THEIR ABILITY IN ATTRACTING CUSTOMERS AND TRUST AND EFFECTIVELY COMMUNICATE. (17)
EMPATHY : IT IS DEMONSTRATE AND APPLIED SPECIAL AND WARM ATTENTION TO CUSTOMER. (4)
Mobilization OF RESOURCES : IT IS THE MAIN ACTIVITIES OF FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS AND BANKS THAT INCLUDED ATTRACT MONEY AND CAPITAL OF WISDOM, HUGE AND CUSTOMERS' EXTRA AND THEIR MAINTENANCE AS CURRENT AND SAVINGS LOAN ACCOUNTS, DEPOSITS OF SHORT-TERM INVESTMENTS, AND VARIETY OF DEPOSITS OF LONG-TERM INVESTMENTS IN BANK FINANCIAL STATEMENTS. (18)

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY IS DESCRIPTIVE TYPE OF CAUSAL. DESCRIPTIVE RESEARCH INCLUDED COLLECTION METHODS THAT THEIR PURPOSE IS DESCRIBE UNDER STUDY CONDITIONS OR PHENOMENA (11). THIS RESEARCH IN TERMS OF PURPOSE IS APPLIED. STATISTICAL POPULATION IS BANK CUSTOMERS GUILAN. FOR SAMPLING IS USED CLUSTER SAMPLING METHOD. THE SAMPLE SIZE ACCORDING TO UNLIMITED COMMUNITY WITH REFER TO MORGAN TABLE IS ESTIMATED 385 NUMBER. COLLECTION INSTRUMENT IN THIS STUDY IS THE QUESTIONNAIRE.

VALIDATED OF QUESTIONNAIRE
FOR DETERMINE THE RELIABILITY IN THIS RESEARCH IS USED THECRONBACH'S ALPHA. HOWEVER, CRONBACH'S ALPHA BE CLOSE TO 1, QUESTIONS ARE MORE RELIABLE (16). THE RESULTS ARE AS FOLLOWS :
image

METHODS OF DATA ANALYSIS
DATA ANALYSIS IS PROVIDED IN TWO METHODS, DESCRIPTIVE STATISTICS EXPRESSION OF THE STUDIED SAMPLES PROPERTIES AND ALSO INFERENTIAL STATISTICS FOR DATA ANALYSIS BY SPSS SOFTWARE.

HYPOTHESIS TEST RESULTS
THE MAIN HYPOTHESIS : THERE ARE SIGNIFICANT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DIMENSIONS OF BANKING SERVICES QUALITY AND BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization.
image
ACCORDING TO THE OBTAIN RESULTS, IT CAN BE SEEN THAT AMOUNT OF SIG. IS LESS THAN %5. FOR THIS REASON THIS RELATIONSHIP WAS SIGNIFICANT, SO H1 IS ACCEPTED.
THE FIRST SUB-HYPOTHESIS : THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DIMENSION OF TANGIBLE FACTORS AND BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization.
image
ACCORDING TO THE OBTAIN RESULTS, IT CAN BE SEEN THAT AMOUNT OF SIG. IS LESS THAN %5. FOR THIS REASON THIS RELATIONSHIP WAS SIGNIFICANT, SO H1 IS ACCEPTED.
THE SECOND SUB-HYPOTHESIS : THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DIMENSION OF DEPENDABILITY AND BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization.
image
ACCORDING TO THE OBTAIN RESULTS, IT CAN BE SEEN THAT AMOUNT OF SIG. IS LESS THAN %5. FOR THIS REASON THIS RELATIONSHIP WAS SIGNIFICANT, SO H1 IS ACCEPTED.
THE THIRD SUB-HYPOTHESIS : THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DIMENSION OF ACCOUNTABILITY AND BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization.
image
ACCORDING TO THE OBTAIN RESULTS, IT CAN BE SEEN THAT AMOUNT OF SIG. IS LESS THAN %5. FOR THIS REASON THIS RELATIONSHIP WAS SIGNIFICANT, SO H1 IS ACCEPTED.
THE FOURTH SUB-HYPOTHESIS : THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DIMENSION OF RELIABILITY AND BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization.
image
image
ACCORDING TO THE OBTAIN RESULTS, IT CAN BE SEEN THAT AMOUNT OF SIG. IS LESS THAN %5. FOR THIS REASON THIS RELATIONSHIP WAS SIGNIFICANT, SO H1 IS ACCEPTED.
THE FIFTH SUB-HYPOTHESIS : THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DIMENSION OF EMPATHY AND BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization.
image
ACCORDING TO THE OBTAIN RESULTS, IT CAN BE SEEN THAT AMOUNT OF SIG. IS LESS THAN %5. FOR THIS REASON THIS RELATIONSHIP WAS SIGNIFICANT, SO H1 IS ACCEPTED.

CONCLUSIONS
EFFECT INTENSITY DIMENSIONS OF BANKING SERVICES QUALITY ON THE BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization IS EQUAL TO %52.3. ACCORDING TO BETA DIRECTION OF THIS IMPACT IS STRAIGHT. ALSO THE COEFFICIENT OF DETERMINATION BETWEEN TWO VARIABLES IS EQUAL TO 0.274. EFFECT INTENSITY TANGIBLE FACTORS FROM DIMENSIONS OF BANKING SERVICES QUALITY ON THE BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization IS EQUAL TO %28.4. ACCORDING TO BETA DIRECTION OF THIS IMPACT IS STRAIGHT. ALSO THE COEFFICIENT OF DETERMINATION BETWEEN TWO VARIABLES IS EQUAL TO 0.081. EFFECT INTENSITY DEPENDABILITY FROM DIMENSIONS OF BANKING SERVICES QUALITY ON THE BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization IS EQUAL TO %45.1. ACCORDING TO BETA DIRECTION OF THIS IMPACT IS STRAIGHT. ALSO THE COEFFICIENT OF DETERMINATION BETWEEN TWO VARIABLES IS EQUAL TO 0.212. EFFECT INTENSITY ACCOUNTABILITY FROM DIMENSIONS OF BANKING SERVICES QUALITY ON THE BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization IS EQUAL TO %48.8. ACCORDING TO BETA DIRECTION OF THIS IMPACT IS STRAIGHT. ALSO THE COEFFICIENT OF DETERMINATION BETWEEN TWO VARIABLES IS EQUAL TO 0.238. EFFECT INTENSITY RELIABILITY FROM DIMENSIONS OF BANKING SERVICES QUALITY ON THE BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization IS EQUAL TO %40. ACCORDING TO BETA DIRECTION OF THIS IMPACT IS STRAIGHT. ALSO THE COEFFICIENT OF DETERMINATION BETWEEN TWO VARIABLES IS EQUAL TO 0.16. EFFECT INTENSITY EMPATHY FROM DIMENSIONS OF BANKING SERVICES QUALITY ON THE BANKING RESOURCE Mobilization IS EQUAL TO %50. ACCORDING TO BETA DIRECTION OF THIS IMPACT IS STRAIGHT. ALSO THE COEFFICIENT OF DETERMINATION BETWEEN TWO VARIABLES IS EQUAL TO 0.25. IN GENERAL, THE RESULTS OBTAINED ALL RESEARCH HYPOTHESES WERE CONFIRMED.

SUGGESTIONS OF RESEARCH
1. DUE TO INCREASED COMPETITION BETWEEN BANKS AND FINANCIAL - CREDIT INSTITUTIONS AND CAPITAL MARKETS PROVIDE SERVICE IN ADORNED ENVIRONMENTS AND HAVING PHYSICAL AND PSYCHOSOCIAL AND SOCIAL PARAMETERS OF THE STANDARD IS DETERMINING FACTOR IN Mobilization OF BANKING RESOURCES.
2. MAKE SURE IN CUSTOMERS THROUGH DESIRED BEHAVIORS AND MAINTAINING THEIR SECRETS, CUSTOMERS' FEEL SAFE IN THEIR INTERACTIONS WITH BANKS AT THE TIME OF PARTICIPATION OR BENEFIT FROM SERVICES PROCESS CAN STRENGTHEN THEIR FEEL CONFIDENT.
3. SHOWING GENUINE INTEREST FOR SOLVE THE CUSTOMER'S PROBLEM IN LESS TIME, PERFORMED REFORMS IN BANKING SERVICES IN FIRST TIME, PRESENTING FINANCIAL REPORTS BE LEAD TO INCREASE LOYALTY, AND THEREFORE WILL BE RISING BANK FUNDING.
4. MATCHING TOOLS AND SERVICE DELIVERY PROCEDURES WITH CULTURE, ATTITUDES AND KNOWLEDGE OF THE PEOPLE.
5. EXPANDING THE USE OF VIRTUAL BANKING FACILITIES FOR SPECIFIC CUSTOMERS.

SUGGESTIONS FOR FUTURE RESEARCH
1. IDENTIFICATION OF NEW BANKING SERVICES AND THEIR IMPLEMENTATION FEASIBILITY IN MELLI BANK
2. REVIEWS HUMAN RESOURCES QUALITY IN ORGANIZATION'S ACTIVITIES AND ITS IMPACT ON ORGANIZATION FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE.
3. REVIEWS OF EMPLOYEE BEHAVIOR FACTORS IN CUSTOMER LOYALTY.
4. STUDY OF EFFECTIVE FACTORS ON THE DEPOSITS IN THE BANKING SYSTEM
5. PROVIDED OPERATIONAL MODEL FOR ASSESS BANKING SERVICES QUALITY IN BRANCHES

LIMITATIONS OF RESEARCH
1. MULTIPLICITY AND GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION MELLI BANK BRANCHES IN THE BRANCHES
2. CUSTOMERS' LACK OF COOPERATION IN RESPONDING TO QUESTIONS
3. TIME CONSTRAINTS FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF RESEARCH

References
  1. Angur M.G nataraajan R &jaheraJr J.S. Service quality in the banking industry:an assessment in a developing ecinimy. internationaljornal of bank marketing ,17(3),pp.116-123. 1999
  2. Asadi, Darab. Study of Success Key Factors of banks in attract resources non-accrual (Savings and current loan) in Maskan Bank. 2011
  3. FaghihAkhlaghi, Hasan. Measuring the quality of Maskan Bank Based on the SERVQUAL model (Maskan Bank, Supervision Unit Guilan). 2010
  4. Farsijani, Hasan. Zandi, Omid. Explanations and evaluating management strategic model. Journal of Management Strategic Studies. No. 1. 2010
  5. Feizi, Mohsen. Study of Effective Factors on the Mobilization of resources (Deposits) in Kermanshah Melli Bank. 2010
  6. GhaderiSomayeh Et al. Review and Measuring of Services quality and its relationship with customer satisfaction : Case Study Tejarat Bank. 2012
  7. Ghobadian,Abby Et al. Service Quality:Concepts and Models”,InternationalJuornal of Quality And Reliability management , 1994 ,pp. 43-66. 1994
  8. Gronroos ,Christian. Service management and marketing. ,johnwiley&sons.Ltd. 2000
  9. Houn-Gee.c,Yu-ChihLiu.J,ShinSheu.T,Yang.M.H. The impact of financial services quality and fairness on customer satisfaction , Managing Service Quality,Vol. 22 No. 4,pp. 399-421. 2012
  10. Kavousi, Seyed Mohammad Reza. Saghaei, Abbas. Methods of Measuring Customer Satisfaction. Tehran. Publication of Ameh. First Edition. 2009
  11. Khaki, Gholamreza. Research Methodology in Management. Second edition. Islamic Azad University. 2003
  12. MahdilooTazehkandi, Ali. Evaluation and Assessment of Service Quality in Parsian Bank and its Relationship with Customer Sat isfaction. 2009
  13. Mir Sepasi, Naser. Strategic Management of Human Resources and Labor Relations with Outlook on Globalization. Tehran. Publication Mir. 27Th Edition. 2007
  14. Parasuraman, A., Zeithaml, V. A., & Berry, L. L. A conceptual model of service quality and its implications for future research. Journal of Marketing, 49(3), 41-50.1985
  15. Stafford MarlaRoyne, Et al, Determine of sernice quality and satisfaction in the Auto Casualty Claims Process”, journal of service marketing,12(6),426-440. 1998
  16. Skaran, Ouma. Research Methodology in Management. 2007
  17. Thabet A. Edris, Services considered important to business customers and determinants of bank selection in Kuwait: a segmentation analysis, International Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol. 15 Iss: 4, pp.126 – 133. 1997
  18. Ziaei, Mohammad Sadegh. Farzad, Ziviar. Javad, Nargesian. Factors Affecting on the Customer Satisfaction Using SERVQUAL model. Journal of Modern Marketing researches. Second Years. No. 3. 2012
  19. Zhu, F. X., Wymer, W. J., & Chen, I,. IT-based services and service quality in consumer banking. International Journal of Service Industry Management, 13(1), 69-90.2002